Showing posts with label leadership. Show all posts
Showing posts with label leadership. Show all posts

Sunday, July 29, 2018

What do you do when a kid beats your solution?

We were asked, "Has a software engineering interviewee ever come up with a better solution than the expected best answer?"

The question told me that the one who posed it hadn't done many interviews. As an interviewee, I did this often, though it was often met with defensiveness from the interviewer.

As an interviewer, it happens to me all the time, and I've tried awfully hard not to be defensive as I'd seen so many interviewers become.

Once on the job, too, software engineers frequently come up with better answers than their managers, teammates, or team leaders knew and expected. Or, I must admit, better than their consultants.

When this happens in any of these situations, it's important for the interviewer, manager, team leader, teammate, or consultant to accept the answer graciously, thanking the person for teaching them something new.

Even if the new idea isn't "better," if it's new, it's an opportunity to learn, so you don't want to spend your efforts trashing the idea. Just take in into your mind and offer thanks.

When I was a little boy, my father challenged me to learn something new every day before allowing myself to go to bed. Learning new things all the time is perhaps the most important behavior in my life. It's certainly the most important behavior in our profession

Generally, the most powerful learning occurs  when someone produces a better solution than you had imagined. If your ego cannot deal with “better” or even “different” solutions to problems you pose, you have no business being in a leadership position in software engineering.

Or maybe anywhere.




Saturday, July 21, 2018

Some Advice on Advice

I was asked, "I'm very bad at taking my own advice but love helping people with their own personal issues. Does that make me a hypocrite?"

You seem to equate “advice” with helping people, but there are many other ways to help people without offering advice. And, of course quite frequently, even the best advice doesn't help at all.

(Note that I wrote “offering,” not “giving.” You offer, but they need not accept. Nor do you have to accept your own advice. You test it in your mind, or with small actions, and either follow or not, depending on the test’s outcome.)

If you like helping, try asking people what kind (if any) help they want from you. Perhaps they merely want a friendly listener. Or a pat on the back. Or a kick in the rear. Maybe they want you to clean their house. Or carry their heavy package. Maybe they just want a smile.


Stop worrying about labels like “hypocrite,” and start seeking ways to help people the way they want to be helped. Forget the advice business. As Ambrose Bierce says in The Devil’s Dictionary, “Advice is the smallest common coin.”

Thursday, May 31, 2018

Can a Boss Take Corrections From Subordinates?

We were asked, "can a boss take corrections from subordinates?"

Certainly, some bosses can, but there are ways you can increase the chances of changing your boss, or at least your boss's mind.

I think that if the subordinate offers “corrections,” the leader is less likely to respond less well than if the offer is for “information.” That principle actually goes both ways. Most people are somewhat reluctant to take “corrections.”

So, if you are asking how you, as the underling, can “correct” your boss, I suggest you learn how to offer (not “give”) information. The boss can then decide whether or not to act on this new information, and how to do it. 

Again, this goes both ways. Leaders do better offering information than correction.


What Did You Say?: The Art of Giving and Receiving Feedback Revised Second Edition

So, study the feedback process and become proficient. That will be your best chance, but be prepared for failure. Some people simply will not change, even if banged on the head with a two-by-four.

If your boss happens to be one of those frozen people, it will be up to you to do the changing.

Maybe change your behavior. 

Maybe change jobs.






Sunday, May 27, 2018

The Anti-Esteem Tool Kit

The self-esteem tool kit consists of tools you can use to build your self-esteem. For instance, the wishing stick (or wand) reminds you that it's okay to think about what you want, instead of always deferring to the desires of others. Or, the thinking cap reminds you that it's okay to come to your own conclusions about what's going on in the world.

These tools all help you to raise your self-esteem, but there's another tool kit, one that helps you remember to put aside certain tactics that simply help you to maintain low self-esteem. Here's some examples:

The Bully Club: Low self-esteem people often think they can feel better if they hurt other people. Sometimes they think the Courage Stick is a form of bully club, but that's a mistake.

The Blame Pointer: Low-self esteem people are often found pointing the finger of blame at others.

The Blindfold: This tool enables a person to go through life not seeing anything they don't want to see.

The Earplugs: By plugging their ears, people are able to avoid hearing anything that might make them uncomfortable. Some Earplugs replace all sound with distracting music. Some just totally deafen to all sounds. Both the Blindfold and the Earplugs counteract the positive effects of the Golden Key, a tool that allows you to open any inquiry you're puzzled about.

The Nose Clamp: This double-duty tool keeps their wearer from remembering to breathe with their Oxygen Mask. It also prevents the wearer from smelling the stink that everyone else is aware of in a situation.

The Stupid Pill: A single one of these pills drugs one's mind to counteract the effects of wearing a Thinking Cap which would otherwise have you thinking as clearly as possible.

The Last Aid Kit: - Use this to bandage your wounds after agreeing to requests you can’t fulfil because you did not use your Yes/No medallion.

Do any of these tools remind you of any politicians you know?

So, what other anti-esteem tools do you have in your tool kit?


For more on the Self-Esteem Tool Kit, get yourself a copy of More Secrets of Consulting: The Consultant's Tool Kit.


Saturday, May 05, 2018

What is the difference between a good manager and a bad manager?

Because a previous blog of mine asked about good and bad managers, the question naturally came up about what's the difference.

There are, of course, many ways to be a bad manager. Or a good manager. But if I’d been asked for a single difference (and you didn’t use the plural) I’d say that the First Law of Bad Management is this:

If what you’re doing isn’t working, do more of it, faster and louder.


For more on good vs. bad management, take a look at 

Saturday, April 28, 2018

Stumbles for New Leaders and Managers


We were asked, "What were your greatest stumbling blocks as a new manager?"

Paige’s article is a terrific introduction to this subject. 

These are the four rookie manager mistakes described in the article:

Rookie mistake #1: Creating a blanket policy for one bad apple

Rookie mistake #2: Embracing the mantra, “do as I say, not as I do”

Rookie mistake #3: Fixing things that aren’t really broken

Rookie mistake #4: Not taking an interest in your employees’ futures

In my career, I’ve made all four of those mistakes, and lots of others. But the one I most remember, and most regret, is micromanaging.

Somehow, I couldn’t believe that other people could solve problems as effectively as I (thought I) could. My mantra was something like “for your own good,” or “for the organization’s good.”

It took me far too long to learn that other people’s solutions were simply other solutions than mine. Some might be worse than mine. Some might even be better. But most of all, they usually solved whatever problems we were dealing with. There was no need for me to push in with my approach.

I’ve gradually learned to reduce this micromanaging behavior. (I’ve never learned to stop completely.) As I’ve succeeded, I’ve noticed:

* people learn faster when allowed to make their own mistakes

* people listen to me more attentively on those few occasions when I do intervene

* I have more time for doing my own job

I strongly suggest that you loosen your grip on your own ideas and allow your employees and co-workers to implement theirs.


Wednesday, April 25, 2018

Leaders: Smart-but-evil versus Dull-but-good? 

Who's better in a leadership position, a smart but evil person or an unintelligent but good person?

There are different kinds of unintelligent people. For one thing, some not-so-smart folks know they’re not so smart and have learned some simple tactics to cope with their inadequate intelligence.

For instance, in managing software, such managers will refrain from micromanaging their programmers, whereas the smart-evil person is quite likely to interfere with the development and testing work.

What you want in a manager is a person who knows how and when to delegate, understands their own limitations, and cares about improving the environment for all the people on the staff. You don’t have to be all that smart to do that.

But if you are an evil person, your intelligence may be serving the wrong master. It may happen that your intelligent moves help your employees, but that’s not what you’re attempting to do, so it’s hit or miss.




Monday, April 09, 2018

How can I become a software developer who only designs?

A young programmer asked me, "How can I become a software developer who only designs the whole software architecture and gives instructions to other developers rather than actually coding by myself?"

I told him he could do that right away, as long as he didn’t care if the other developers listened to his instructions and followed them. And if he didn't care of he was paid.

In general, software developers will not follow the lead of someone for whose designs they have no respect. And why would they respect your designs unless you had previously proved yourself by what you’ve built?

So, build things, and build more things, until you demonstrate that others have some reason to follow your lead.


And, at the same time, work on your people skills, because even if you’re the greatest designer in the world, if you’re a self-centered jerk, nobody will follow you or your designs.

For more on designing, see

Sunday, October 08, 2017

How Can I Have More Leadership?

I was asked, "How Can I Have More Leadership?"

Many people were interested in my answer, even though I'm not sure whether this question means

How can I have more leadership applied to me?

or 

How can I provide more leadership for others?

In some ways, it's the same question either way. Why? Because if you want more leadership applied to you, the primary way to get it is to provide it yourself.

There are many things you could do to provide more leadership, but I would suggest that before you do any of them, set your mind firmly on this definition of leadership:

“Leadership is the ability to enhance the environment so that everybody is empowered to contribute creatively to the task.”

Don’t forget any of the key words. Check them out when you’re about to do something you think of as “leading.”

  • enhance: you’re making the environment better in some way, and there's lots of way to do that, not one single "leader" way

  • for everybody involved, so make sure what you think is an enhancement is really that for everybody

  • so they’re empowered, which doesn’t mean forced or ordered, especially not by you

  • creatively, not in some stupid or mindless way, and not necessarily in the way you would do it

  • and stay on task, for your job is not to fix everyone else, but to help the job at hand get done

If you keep these things in mind, you won’t always be perfect at leading, but with practice you’ll get better and better, with fewer blunders.




Wednesday, August 30, 2017

How Does One Manage an Incompetent Manager?

How Does One Manage an Incompetent Manager?

The questioner does not say whether the manager's is their boss or employee, but I'll answer assuming they're the employee. If they're the boss, they should manage the same way they would manage any of their employees who is not competent to do the job they're paid for.

This is not just one question because there are quite a few different breeds of incompetent managers. To take just two examples, some are incompetent because they don’t interact with their employees at all, while others micromanage with a vengeance. It seems clear that you’d want to handle each situation in its own unique way.

If your manager is invisible, leaving you alone, just be thankful and go about your business. Believe me, you’re lucky.

For me, the first step in managing a micro-manager is to leave. Find another job, with different manager. A better one.

As for other managerial symptoms of incompetence, you can try working with the manager as one person to another, but realize that this amounts to taking on a second job. If you’re not a a trained psychologist, you might be better just leaving this one alone.

But if you decide you have the skills to manage your manager, do it the way a competent manager would. That is, concentrate on the question, “How is this manager interfering with the work we are being paid to do?” If their incompetence isn’t interfering in a significant way, maybe offer a bit of feedback, but only once, and then get on with your paying job.

In many cases, someone you perceive as incompetent can be a lot easier to live with than to fix. They may not even be as incompetent as you believe.

But if you're seeking advice on a particular pattern of incompetence, write me a note or comment. I will try to help you with specific actions to take.

Oh, and by the way, if you’re neither this manager’s boss or employee, then it’s none of your business, so just leave it alone. There are more incompetent managers in the world than you can possibly cure.

Here's a couple of books you might find helpful:







Tuesday, October 25, 2016

Leaders: Born or Made?

The question was asked: "What's the best way to explain the phrase 'leaders are born not made'?"

That's easy. The best explanation is that it’s pure bunk, not supported by any evidence whatsoever.

But if it’s bunk, why do people repeat it? Perhaps they are making an excuse for not being a leader themselves, and not doing anything about it.

If they did want to do something about it, they could find many resources to help them grow into a better leader. My own contributions include:




and



But I'm not the only leadership coach. You have many choices, so if  you catch yourself arguing that leaders are born not made, stop making excuses. 

If you want to stop making excuses and start making a leader out of yourself, find yourself a collection of coaches and get busy with the making. 

Thursday, June 16, 2016

What's something I can do right now to increase my productivity?

I was recently invited to answer the question in the heading. There were already 99 other answers, some of them very interesting. I tried reading all the answers, but gave up after the first two dozen or so. All that stuff about lists and apps and schedules and methods with trademarked-names might have been okay for some folks, but they didn't do much for me. I don't really use any of them, but I’ve been an incredibly productive person all my life.

I've published around a hundred widely acclaimed books, plus hundreds of articles. I've invented useful things and won a handful of awards for my writing. More than ten thousand people follow my tweets and my workshops are filled with people from all over the world. While doing all these things, I've also found the time and energy to support many volunteer causes.

My secret? I can do all these things because I apply just one principle:

Do what you love doing.

If you love it, you won’t need any of this tricks and tips. You might use some of them or make your own if they help you do what you love, but if you’re not doing what you love, no tricks will help much.

But, you say, "there are just some things I have to do, whether I love them or not." Well, first of all, re-examine those things and make a NOT-TO-DO list, to remind you to stop doing things you hate and don’t really have to do. And if there are still things left that you think you must do, experiment.

For instance, stop doing them for a few days or so and see if it matters. I remember when I had a job where we were supposed to put out a daily report for our manager’s manager’s manager. I started doing it every other day, and nothing happened. I switched to once a week, but again nothing happened. I cut down to once a month. Nothing.

After seven months, this senior manager finally came raging into my office demanding his daily report. I calmed him down and showed him what it had cost to do it daily when he only needed it maybe once a year. We negotiated a deal where on the day he needed it, I would drop everything and produce it in about two hours. That gave him what he needed and saved me two hours a day, 199 working days a year. Now, that’s productive.

But you may still have to accomplish a task that’s really needed, so your experiments don’t work. In that case, examine HOW you accomplish the task and use your imagination to find a way to do it that you really enjoy. For example, you can make a game of the task.

For instance, I once had a rather dull report I had to write regularly so I started each time by picking ten words at random from a large dictionary. Then I challenged myself to use all ten words somewhere in my report. Not only did this make the report into fun game, but I improved both my writing and my vocabulary. And, oh yes, people told me they enjoyed reading those reports, so maybe it made them more productive, tool.

If you enjoy doing a task, you won’t procrastinate, and you’ll do it with gusto. Voila! You’re now the most productive person around.

Not only does this principle work for you, but you can teach it to those who work with you, principally by example. When you do this, you're practicing a powerful form of leadership, helping all those other people be more productive. Think of it this way: It's the opposite of the dreaded micro-management. Instead of telling people how to do things your  way, you're encouraging them to find their was to do things so they'll be a productive as you are.

(You think I’m making this all up? Well, how many people do you know who have accomplished what I’ve accomplished. You can check my website (www.geraldmweinberg.com) and then find some other people with a comparable history and ask them if they enjoy what they do, all day. I don't think you'll find many of them who spend their day making lists—unless they've made it into a list-making game.

Tuesday, May 24, 2016

What is the truth about 10x programmers?

Way back when I wrote The Psychology of Computer Programming, I pointed out the wide variation in programming skills. Years later, people began labeling this phenomenon 10x programmers.

On the Quora website recently, a participant asked "What is the truth about 10x programmers?"

Most of the answers there were good, but misguided. Many of today’s critical programming tasks are simply too big and complex to be handled even by a 100x programmer (not to speak of maintaining what a 100x programmer produces but does not want to be bothered maintaining).
For many years now, we have understood that the programming job is not really a job for individuals, but for teams. (Yes, an individual can produce a fine small program, such as a game. I have done that myself, many times over 60 years in the business.) So what we really want is a 10x leader/teacher of programmers. If you can’t pass on you 10x abillities to others, you’re not what we want for those enormous programming tasks.
That’s why I now concentrate on teaching 10x programmers to be 10x programming leaders, as in my Problem Solving Leadership workshops and my books such as Becoming a Technical Leader.

Monday, May 16, 2016

Why Agile Projects Sometimes Fail


The gang was enjoying a BBQ Pig Out at Rudy's. It was a magical moment until Rusty and Millie started to argue about Agile software development.

Rusty started it all by saying, "Agile is magical."

Millie banged on the table with a half-chewed pork rib. "That's ridiculous. There's nothing magical about it."

"Sure there is." Rusty pulled a Sharpie out of his pocket protector and printed "AGILE" on a paper towel (which passes for a napkin in Rudy's). "There are just a few things management has to provide—like MONEY." He sketched a capital M on the towel, making MAGILE.

"Money's not enough," said Millie.

"Of course not. Management has to eliminate environmental interference.' With one smooth stroke, he crossed out the "E."

Millie frowned and shook her head, but Rusty took no notice. "And they need to Cooperate, and not just occasionally, but All the time." He added the C and A, finally producing "MAGICAL."

"Cute," said Millie, her tone sarcastic, but she was clearing struggling not to smile. "But successful projects require more than waving a Sharpie wand and pronouncing 'AgileCadabra.'"

We all knew that Rusty was pulling our legs. Millie, of course, was right. If you want to succeed with an Agile approach, you need more than magic rituals. Not only that, you need to avoid quite a few rather common mistakes that lead to failure.

Common Mistakes in Building New Things

In my experience, these common mistakes are not unique to Agile projects, but will kill Agile projects just as easily as they kill Waterfall or any other approach:

1. Committing to a schedule or cost without having any relevant experience with this type of project.

2. Using the experience on a similar but smaller project to commit to an estimate on a larger project.

3. Extending requirements to "optimize" or beat unknown competition.

4. Failing to recognize signs of impending failure and/or act on them to extend schedules, reduce costly requirements. (like those that diminish velocity by creating more frequent failed tests).

5. Failing to recognize limits of the environment or process or recognizing them but being unwilling to change them.

6. Simply undertaking too many simultaneous tasks and perhaps failing to complete any of them.

7. Not recognizing both changes and opportunities presented by a new technology.

8. Not asking the customer, out of fear, or lack of customer surrogate contact.

9. Not asking anyone for help (fear?).

10. [I invite my readers to contribute more failure dangers to this list.]

The Underlying Failure

Beneath each of these failure reasons, and others, lies one generalized failure. I explain that failure in the remainder of this article, posted as a chapter in my book, Agile Impressions.